Zaza Gabor 29.11.2012 14:18 |
I mean, have Freddie Mercury, Brian May, John Deacon and Roger Taylor ever been know as reading books that influenced them? I know, basically it’s just me trying hard to find a book-reading role-model rock star for kids XD On the other hand, there are many long-term Queen fans, who can compare their erudition here; and it well may become my contribution to the forum if you start to express your opinion should rock stars read books at all LOL |
Doga 29.11.2012 14:42 |
Well, Brian is a Doctor, so i imagine he must read tons and tons of books in his life. |
Ozz 29.11.2012 14:59 |
Brian , for what i remember was into Tolkien and Cs Lewis. I don't remember if it was him or roger that was into Herman Hesse. |
Holly2003 29.11.2012 15:09 |
Ozz wrote: Brian , for what i remember was into Tolkien and Cs Lewis. I don't remember if it was him or roger that was into Herman Hesse.lol! I'd be willing to bet £100 it isn't Roger! |
GratefulFan 29.11.2012 15:17 |
I'm sure there are several examples, particularly with Brian, but I recall specifically the song White Queen from the album Queen II being inspired by Robert Graves' The White Goddess. Brian also cites the work as a primary reason for embracing Freddie's suggestion of 'Queen' for the band name. His 2004 quote follows: "White Queen" - back in time again - I wrote this at College, where I led a relatively sheltered life, even though the University on the whole was a pretty rampant pace! I had been reading "The White Goddess" by Robert Graves, which explored the role of the idealised Virgin/Mother/Queen/ figure in art through history, and the name for our group, decided just around that time, fitted in with this perfectly - which was one of the reasons I was convinced to go with the name. The personal side is bound up with a girl (of course!) whom I saw every day at College, and was to me the ultimate goddess. It's incredible in retrospect, but because I held her in such awe, in three years I never had the courage to speak to tell her, or even speak to her. The song found its way on to tape much later, on our second album." The Graves book he cited is built around imagery and symbolism relating to the phases of the moon and a three faced moon goddess. |
GratefulFan 29.11.2012 15:37 |
Worth mentioning too something we forget that people newer to a more in depth interest in Queen might not know is that Brian May is himself the co-author of a couple of books. One an interesting and accessible book on astronomy: link ...and the other a richly illustrated and more specialized book on T.R. Williams and stereo photography: link |
mooghead 29.11.2012 16:32 |
Freddie must have read Tolkien if side 2 of Queen II is anything to go by, Prophets Song is very Tolkienesque too. They are all very highly educated, I should imagine they read a lot as students. |
Doga 29.11.2012 17:01 |
Yes, Ogre Battle is very influenced by Tolkien |
matt z 29.11.2012 21:23 |
Roger is heavily influenced by Page 3. Freddie is quoted in an interview stating that books are a waste of time |
The Real Wizard 29.11.2012 22:41 |
matt z wrote: Freddie is quoted in an interview stating that books are a waste of timeThat was in the 80s when he became a giant ignoramus. The quality of his work largely went to the shitter, as most of his songs had the same subject matter. In the 70s he was a very cultured person and no doubt he read plenty, which led to an output of a wide variety of songs. |
GratefulFan 30.11.2012 11:47 |
There is little reason to think Freddie was ever a reader of any note. Neither his college courses or what we know of his personal interests and ambitions would have demanded much reading and his interests in culture and history seemed to centre around objects and not knowledge. Peter Freestone who knew his from late '77 said in his book "Freddie loved catalogues because there were lots of pictures and little need to read any text unless the picture caught his eye. Freddie was not a reader. I couldn't tell you the title of any one book which Freddie ever read. His attention span wasn't long enough for him to get stuck into a novel. His boredom threshold was very, very low and his time was too precious, in his terms, to be spent reading when you could get the answer to your questions a lot easier by asking someone." I think that fits anecdotal observations from interviews etc. quite well. One got the impression that Fred was fun loving and sensitive but not particularly introspective or analytical. |
jones904 30.11.2012 12:16 |
dan dare and beano |
Mercury Roadrunner 30.11.2012 12:59 |
Here is some info about Queen's favourite books (and not only books, so sorry for a little offtop, but im sure it will be interesting too) taken from QOIFC magazines' questionnaires: F.Mercury Book: B.Potter "Peter Rabbit" R.Taylor Film: Godfather Clockwork Orange Great Race 2001 King Kong Actor/Actress: Tony Curtis, J.Fonda Book: Jack Keruack "On The Road" Frank Herbert "Dune" B.May Film: Women In Love Book: Herman Hesse "Steppenwolf", "The Glass Bead Game" Actor/Actress: James Mason, Natalie Wood J.Deacon Film: Prime Of Miss Jean Brody and as far as I remember Freddie mentioned in one of these questionnaires in one of the earliest 80s QOIFC mags that one of his fave books is "Around The World" by Joan Davis but I guess he wanted to say that thats one of his fave films (cause the only info I found on that title is the movie of the same name made in 1943 and starring John Davis). Hope that helps. Cheers |
jones904 30.11.2012 13:07 |
Freddie like Einstien was more of a thinker and creator than a follower of other pepples ideas |
Zaza Gabor 30.11.2012 13:39 |
Mercury Roadrunner wrote: Here is some info about Queen's favourite books...Based on this list, I'd say that Freddie is the one who cultivates an anti-intellectual image and John Deacon is the one who doesn't read LOL I was just wandering what Roger Taylor might read... I should know he's into Jack Keruack! |
John S Stuart 30.11.2012 13:52 |
Freddie read poetry. ( Such as Robert Browning's "Pied Piper of Hamelin"). 241 ''Joining the town and just at hand, 242 ''Where waters gushed and fruit-trees grew, 243 ''And flowers put forth a fairer hue, 244 ''And everything was strange and new; 245 ''The sparrows were brighter than peacocks here, 246 ''And their dogs outran our fallow deer, 247 ''And honey-bees had lost their stings, 248 ''And horses were born with eagles' wings; 249 ''And just as I became assured 250 ''My lame foot would be speedily cured, 251 ''The music stopped and I stood still, 252 ''And found myself outside the hill, 253 ''Left alone against my will, 254 ''To go now limping as before, 255 ''And never hear of that country more!'' |
GratefulFan 30.11.2012 14:26 |
Ha ha. I remember plundering through my mother's copy of Kerouac's 'On the Road' when I was about 13 or 14. As I recall, that and 'All the President's Men' were the beginning and end of my teenaged intellectualism. I pretty much stuck with Stephen King after that until I was 18 or so. |
Zaza Gabor 30.11.2012 15:02 |
Talking about Brian's teenage intellectualism, his Wiki page says he named his first high school rock band after Orwell’s 1984 :) |
The Real Wizard 30.11.2012 15:28 |
GratefulFan wrote: his time was too precious, in his terms, to be spent reading when you could get the answer to your questions a lot easier by asking someone.So he refused to listen to anyone outside of his little circle. He was his own worst enemy, and one could easily argue that this attitude of "not giving a fuck" is what ultimately took him. This definitely wasn't Freddie in 1974. This is Freddie in 1984. I'd really like to think this was just a front and that the inquisitive nature of his youth was still in there somewhere. Only he knew.. |
waunakonor 30.11.2012 16:37 |
Zaza Gabor wrote: Talking about Brian's teenage intellectualism, his Wiki page says he named his first high school rock band after Orwell’s 1984 :)More places say that than just his Wiki page, but that is correct. |
Zaza Gabor 30.11.2012 17:12 |
waunakonor wrote: More places say that than just his Wiki page, but that is correct.Good for his Wiki page XD The Real Wizard wrote: I'd really like to think this was just a front and that the inquisitive nature of his youth was still in there somewhere. Only he knew..I'd rather like to know what Brian has said about it. Peter Freestone himself is no intellectual shine to judge, you know, but Brian !! Pretty much a monster prodigy, at least this thread makes him look like one :D |
matt z 30.11.2012 17:57 |
Its good to know that Brian read Hesse... I've read a few; notably Demian and Siddharta, but never read Steppenwolf. I hear ya "Real Wizard" ... Some snobbish cocaine induced party all the time kind of thoughtlessness may have pervaded. I was kinda joking having mentioned"Page 3" God, I hope page 3 is still around. Other notable stuff; Roger was noted as remembering the artwork from sci fi mag "Amazing ----" featuring frank Kelly Freas' work which was redone for NOTW. ALSO: Fun in Space features a sci fi mag. I would guess that Freddie read mythologies and biographies (stars etc)... Plus some basic astrology. Maybe this is something to ask Brian on his soapbox. |
matt z 01.12.2012 04:08 |
The Real Wizard wrote:Silly ASS I am...matt z wrote: Freddie is quoted in an interview stating that books are a waste of timeThat was in the 80s when he became a giant ignoramus. The quality of his work largely went to the shitter, as most of his songs had the same subject matter. In the 70s he was a very cultured person and no doubt he read plenty, which led to an output of a wide variety of songs. You know...I had never given it that consideration until now, BUT. (Big butt) The notion that a man might THINK of his work and what the public would think, was ENTIRELY lost on me until I considered your statements. That's probably very naturally HONEST. And what a shame it didn't amount to enough. MIH: was a triumph, .... Considering |
Zaza Gabor 01.12.2012 13:45 |
matt z wrote: . Maybe this is something to ask Brian on his soapbox.This is the awesomest idea! Who'll do it? I just wonder, shall it be mentioned some fans'd like to know if Freddie brought any catalogues for his bandmates? Ok I'm kidding LOL |
AlbaNo1 01.12.2012 14:04 |
Though obviously intelligent in many ways, none of them come across as being particularly literary in areas that might have helped improve and add depth to some of the lyrics. Its almost as though whatever they did read during their formal education years saw them through the 70s but the lyrics became more trite in the 80s as they had no deep interest in developing as writers. |
tomchristie22 01.12.2012 17:20 |
GratefulFan wrote: I'm sure there are several examples, particularly with Brian, but I recall specifically the song White Queen from the album Queen II being inspired by Robert Graves' The White Goddess. Brian also cites the work as a primary reason for embracing Freddie's suggestion of 'Queen' for the band name. His 2004 quote follows: "White Queen" - back in time again - I wrote this at College, where I led a relatively sheltered life, even though the University on the whole was a pretty rampant pace! I had been reading "The White Goddess" by Robert Graves, which explored the role of the idealised Virgin/Mother/Queen/ figure in art through history, and the name for our group, decided just around that time, fitted in with this perfectly - which was one of the reasons I was convinced to go with the name. The personal side is bound up with a girl (of course!) whom I saw every day at College, and was to me the ultimate goddess. It's incredible in retrospect, but because I held her in such awe, in three years I never had the courage to speak to tell her, or even speak to her. The song found its way on to tape much later, on our second album." The Graves book he cited is built around imagery and symbolism relating to the phases of the moon and a three faced moon goddess.Wow, thanks for posting this. I'd never heard him go into such great detail about the song so I find it very interesting. jones904 wrote: Freddie like Einstien was more of a thinker and creator than a follower of other pepples ideasDon't you think that's giving him a bit much credit for simply not being interested in books? |
GratefulFan 03.12.2012 09:33 |
Zaza Gabor wrote: Talking about Brian's teenage intellectualism, his Wiki page says he named his first high school rock band after Orwell’s 1984 :)Okay I now remember I also read 1984 in my teens. And a whole slew of sci-fi stuff. I'm probably wildly shortchanging my own history as my face was always jammed in some book or other and they can't ALL have been Stephen King. I think that is one of the reasons I was drawn to this thread. Despite being a prolific reader who did everything I could to foster a love of reading in my own child I also have a teenager who simply does not engage with books. Over the years I've learned to understand it, though I've never learned not to regret it for his sake. Like Freddie and so many other bright people he simply can't pull together the particular kind of focus and stillness you need for reading. Despite this he is a bright and inquisitive person with a love of knowledge and so it's been an education for me learning to jettison some of my past assumptions about reading and people who didn't do much of it. |
Zaza Gabor 03.12.2012 19:46 |
AlbaNo1 wrote: Though obviously intelligent in many ways, none of them come across as being particularly literary in areas that might have helped improve and add depth to some of the lyrics. Its almost as though whatever they did read during their formal education years saw them through the 70s but the lyrics became more trite in the 80s as they had no deep interest in developing as writers.This is what happens to most of the adults. It only proves how important this personality development phase is. What I read during my years of formal education is seeing me through the rest of my life in which, I have to admit, my intellectual ambitions hardly rise above a copy of Stephen King or, well, Dan Brown XD so it would be a bit hypocritical to expect professional musicians to be different. GratefulFan wrote: Okay I now remember I also read 1984 in my teens. And a whole slew of sci-fi stuff. I'm probably wildly shortchanging my own history as my face was always jammed in some book or other and they can't ALL have been Stephen King. I think that is one of the reasons I was drawn to this thread. Despite being a prolific reader who did everything I could to foster a love of reading in my own child I also have a teenager who simply does not engage with books. Over the years I've learned to understand it, though I've never learned not to regret it for his sake. Like Freddie and so many other bright people he simply can't pull together the particular kind of focus and stillness you need for reading. Despite this he is a bright and inquisitive person with a love of knowledge and so it's been an education for me learning to jettison some of my past assumptions about reading and people who didn't do much of it.I’m not complaining, there are many reasons why I’m grateful for my kid being the way he is. However, there are at least five or hopefully more (I know everybody complains how useless those college degrees are but show me an employer who wants to see a CV without one) years of formal education ahead of him and I won’t lie that I’m not scared because I am. The chances to learn and discover things he has today may never be here again. That’s true I’m relieved my kid isn’t like Brian. I mean, the type who leads a sheltered life in a college worshipping the most intellectual stuff of Herman Hesse and considering pretty girl a goddess instead of taking her to a party. By God, why did they say Freddie was the one with his nuts loose? This case sounds much worse. At the same time, if I think that Freddie made all the way from Beatrix Potter to Mr. Bad Boy in the 80ties just asking wrong people and getting bad answers, I don’t want that happen to my child. There should be some independence in thinking and the comparison of different sources of information, books being one of them, probably helps. I guess for me, it’s very much like that college thing: happiness doesn’t lie in books but I’m afraid not reading them is even worse alternative XD |
Martin Packer 05.12.2012 02:58 |
|
Martin Packer 05.12.2012 02:59 |
3 little words: "The Invisible Man". :-) |
matt z 05.12.2012 03:59 |
Martin Packer wrote: 3 little words: "The Invisible Man". :-)Suppoose he read Ellison Or Wells? |
Zaza Gabor 05.12.2012 13:59 |
Martin Packer wrote: 3 little words: "The Invisible Man". :-)It's a movie ;-) |
brENsKi 05.12.2012 16:21 |
Freddie was into reading the "health warnings on the back of cigarette packets" Brian had "Horse & Hounds" and "Country Matters" and "Smash hits" delivered every week Roger was really into "Haynes car Manuals - esp 1976 Ford escort" and John's favourite read was leviticus and chronicles from the old testament * one or more of the above may be untrue |
Zaza Gabor 06.12.2012 01:15 |
brENsKi wrote: Freddie was into reading the "health warnings on the back of cigarette packets" Brian had "Horse & Hounds" and "Country Matters" and "Smash hits" delivered every week Roger was really into "Haynes car Manuals - esp 1976 Ford escort" and John's favourite read was leviticus and chronicles from the old testament * one or more of the above may be untrueIF ONLY I COULD add a poll to this topic I'd like you to vote which is most likely untrue LOL |
GratefulFan 06.12.2012 12:25 |
Forgot to add that Herman Hesse was an inspiration for Brian's '39 via his short work 'The Poet', according to Brian. link |
brENsKi 06.12.2012 13:21 |
i would think that currently, Brian's reads may bias toward these: The Tale of Mr. Toad (featuring Tommy Brock) C. S. Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia series. (featuring Trufflehuntera talking badger) the tale of "El-ahrairah in Watership Down. (featuring "Old Brock") The Wind in the Willows (featuring mr Badger) the Tales of Rupert Bear (featuring Bill Badger) |
GratefulFan 06.12.2012 15:11 |
I find the very real and very terrible scourge of disease on wildlife and farming juxtaposed with the pervasive Disneyfication of animals that May et al engage in in service of their cause truly unsettling. There's some surreal thing on his Soapbox about a Christmas number one with a bunch of grown men in fuzzy animal suits dancing around. It all represents totally disordered egocentric thinking with a good helping of fruitcake in my books. |
Holly2003 06.12.2012 15:23 |
lol! There is an element of Professor Frink about Brian at times, hoyvin glavin! |
Zaza Gabor 07.12.2012 22:32 |
brENsKi wrote: i would think that currently, Brian's reads may bias toward these: The Tale of Mr. Toad (featuring Tommy Brock) C. S. Lewis's Chronicles of Narnia series. (featuring Trufflehuntera talking badger) the tale of "El-ahrairah in Watership Down. (featuring "Old Brock") The Wind in the Willows (featuring mr Badger) the Tales of Rupert Bear (featuring Bill Badger)Thank you for not listing all literary sources that feature foxes XD |
Zaza Gabor 07.12.2012 22:43 |
GratefulFan wrote: I find the very real and very terrible scourge of disease on wildlife and farming juxtaposed with the pervasive Disneyfication of animals that May et al engage in in service of their cause truly unsettling. There's some surreal thing on his Soapbox about a Christmas number one with a bunch of grown men in fuzzy animal suits dancing around. It all represents totally disordered egocentric thinking with a good helping of fruitcake in my books.Oh, poor Brian. I feel kind of guilty. Before I started this thread, I honestly thought he's normal. A bit hairy maybe, but still normal. What an awful witness our library card can be. Makes me think of the movie Se7en. If any Disney animator has ever confessed being a huge fan of Hesse’s Steppenwolf, please don’t tell me. I’m not sure I can take it one more time. |
Zaza Gabor 07.12.2012 22:51 |
GratefulFan wrote: Forgot to add that Herman Hesse was an inspiration for Brian's '39 via his short work 'The Poet', according to Brian. linkI wish I knew what that 39’ song is about, I kind of like it by the way, but I have to admit that Hesse’s short story doesn’t seem to give a clue, well, to a no-poet :D If it’s been a trick how to lure innocent people into reading Hesse then it’s just cruel XD |
The Real Wizard 08.12.2012 11:45 |
This excerpt from a 1977 article in Circus magazine reveals the stark difference between artistic 70s Freddie and disposable pop 80s Freddie. |
Zaza Gabor 09.12.2012 05:02 |
Everybody’s so happy about Freddie the Illiterate – me, too, because now I can poke with my finger and say, look what happens if you are illiterate! – but the truth is none of illiterates I know likes ballet. This is what they don’t get, the culture heritage. Obviously there’s been more than just Peter Rabbit that built young Freddie’s universe. Maybe his Mom or Sis will tell one day :-) |
waunakonor 09.12.2012 12:34 |
The Real Wizard wrote:Might I ask exactly what that subject matter was?matt z wrote: Freddie is quoted in an interview stating that books are a waste of timeThat was in the 80s when he became a giant ignoramus. The quality of his work largely went to the shitter, as most of his songs had the same subject matter. |
The Real Wizard 09.12.2012 18:04 |
waunakonor wrote:Relationships.The Real Wizard wrote:Might I ask exactly what that subject matter was?matt z wrote: Freddie is quoted in an interview stating that books are a waste of timeThat was in the 80s when he became a giant ignoramus. The quality of his work largely went to the shitter, as most of his songs had the same subject matter. From 1982 to 1986, this was 90% of Mercury's output, for better or for worse. |
GratefulFan 11.12.2012 12:20 |
Fred of course said all his songs were about love. Not completely accurate, but not far off. Wasn't that always pretty much so? There are probably much, much better explanations for his personal and professional evolution than the fact that he didn't read books. |
The Real Wizard 11.12.2012 21:25 |
Indeed, and we'll likely never know. As for the quote, it was from the mid 80s, during a time when nearly every song he wrote was on that topic. You definitely couldn't say the same for 1975. |
jones904 11.12.2012 22:01 |
Freddie had a very in depth top of the market now out of print concise book on roman and Greek mythology a notoriously intellectual and very deep subject which spans both cultural & historical interests and is scattered throughout the great arts and literature, so there. |