I'm probably the only one who thinks that the stuff Pink Floyd did after Roger Waters left was still good.
I seriously can't see what's so wrong with it.
For me it's simple: I can't listen to David Gilmour's voice for an hour.
Jaaaawn...
And Syd?
"Won't you miss me?
Wouldn't you miss me at aaaaaall?"
'Course we do...
I absolutely adore Syd. I love Roger, too, but they're like two completely different bands. They both made the band what it was, and they are both geniuses.
We miss you, Syd!! :)
And about the Gilmour stuff, I think Dave is a first rate guitar player and vocalist. However, as a songwriter after Roger left, I don't think he could really stand on his own. I don't really like the post-Waters Floyd at all.