| Saif 28.02.2007 11:16 |
I mean the albums, not the bands. Well I mean the bands too... Which is the better album? Which is the better band? |
| sparrow 21754 28.02.2007 11:22 |
i love them both, but ive loved queen longer. its a tough choice. funny you ask im wearing a zeppelin t-shirt right now! |
| Saif 28.02.2007 11:31 |
Which is the better debut album then? =P |
| sparrow 21754 28.02.2007 11:57 |
hehe well i do love queens debut album, its actually that and ANATO are my favorites, depending on the day. but i do love zeppelin's early work altogether, but depends on the day, yet again. i have yet to collect all their albums. i dont feel like a real zeppelin fan >.< but i do love them. i just have 'houses of the holy' and 'early and latter years'. so ill start my collection soon. i apologize :-p i cant really answer the question. :( |
| Mr.Jingles 28.02.2007 12:05 |
I'm not too fond of Led Zeppelin's first albums even though a lot of people consider them their best. I found that I, II, and III were too blues oriented. They're good indeed, but I find them quite overated. I think Led Zep reached their true potential from Zoso until Physical Graffitti. |
| john bodega 28.02.2007 12:14 |
Man.... ask me which leg to cut off why don't you??! |
| user name 28.02.2007 12:24 |
What Zebonka said. Although, to be honest, I consider both albums to be on the weaker end of both bands' catalogues. They both had really good songs, but they both had songs I really couldn't care less for. |
| its_a_hard_life 26994 28.02.2007 13:14 |
Queeeeeeeeeeeeeeen. [: I love Led Zep too though. But me go for the Queenies. =D |
| deleted user 28.02.2007 15:09 |
QUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN. =]]]] Led Zeppelin is awesome too though...album-wise :P |
| Nathan 28.02.2007 15:34 |
Led Zeppelin. But Queen is very special too. |
| Matias Merçeauroix 28.02.2007 15:46 |
You know what I think of Led Zeppeshit |
| Dan C. 28.02.2007 16:15 |
I've never liked Led Zeppelin. |
| blerp 28.02.2007 19:44 |
Led Zeppelin! |
| Saif 28.02.2007 22:29 |
Damn so many people HATE Led Zeppelin. =( IMO, deciding between Queen and LZ is like choosing between two identical twins. They're very different but still so similar and equally lovable. But as for debut albums, I personally think Queen I has far more to offer musically than Led Zeppelin I and is better... |
| Oszmercury 01.03.2007 00:50 |
Well Queen I sounds very zeppelinesque, only that has May's guitar, freddie's singing is very Plantish. They're different kind of bands, but for albums, i go with the zepp |
| unknown 01.03.2007 06:44 |
Queen I is in fact influenced by Led Zeppelin, but I think such early unique Queen compositions like 'My Fairy King' cannot be compared to any other band or musician. In terms of conceptual albums I'd say Led Zeppelin II is slightly better than Queen's ANATO. But as a band, I like Queen more, because they have more variety in their music. |
| Saif 01.03.2007 07:55 |
There wouldn't be any Queen without LZ. I'd say Led Zeppelin II is better than Queen II but A Night At The Opera? They're too different IMO to compare, LZ was never art/progressive rock so they never struggled for excellence. |
| Mr.Jingles 01.03.2007 09:05 |
Physical Graffitti is the only Led Zeppelin album that is arguably as good as Queen II. That's just my opinion. |
| Matias Merçeauroix 01.03.2007 12:17 |
I can't believe what I'm reading it's too much I think I'm gonna faint ... led zep pfffffft ¬¬' |
| unknown 01.03.2007 12:23 |
|
| unknown 01.03.2007 12:25 |
Saif wrote: There wouldn't be any Queen without LZ. I'd say Led Zeppelin II is better than Queen II but A Night At The Opera? They're too different IMO to compare, LZ was never art/progressive rock so they never struggled for excellence.I agree with you; I just meant that Led Zeppelin II was better than ANATO as a whole, i.e. in it's 'continuity' - this is only my opinion;) The reason is as I listened to Led Zeppelin II for the first time approx 3 or 4 years ago - being already a Queen fan and owning all their albums - I was amazed by it and liked all the songs on it while on ANATO, I'm not in particular fond of 'I'm In Love With My Car' and 'Sweet Lady' (again; my personal taste:)) I feel the same for 'Dark Side Of The Moon' by Pink Floyd; personally, I like this album better than ANATO because of its structure/continuity, but in terms of songs I think no song of DSOTM can reach the excellence of 'Bohemian Rhapsody'. |
| Saif 01.03.2007 12:47 |
<b><font color=B22222>daria wrote:Yeah, DSOTM is a good example of album-oriented rock. Non of the tracks were MAJOR hit singles but the album is considered a classic and as far as I know, it's the best-selling classic rock album of the Nielsen Soundscan era with over 8 million copies shipped since 1991. I wouldn't say I like all of it though, hearing some tracks makes me drowsy but I love "Brain Damage" and the song after it...forgot the name. "Eclipse" or something like that? My favourite Pink Floyd album is Wish You Were Here though, all the tracks are good except maybe "Have A Cigar".Saif wrote: There wouldn't be any Queen without LZ. I'd say Led Zeppelin II is better than Queen II but A Night At The Opera? They're too different IMO to compare, LZ was never art/progressive rock so they never struggled for excellence.I agree with you; I just meant that Led Zeppelin II was better than ANATO as a whole, i.e. in it's 'continuity' - this is only my opinion;) The reason is as I listened to Led Zeppelin II for the first time approx 3 or 4 years ago - being already a Queen fan and owning all their albums - I was amazed by it and liked all the songs on it while on ANATO, I'm not in particular fond of 'I'm In Love With My Car' and 'Sweet Lady' (again; my personal taste:)) I feel the same for 'Dark Side Of The Moon' by Pink Floyd; personally, I like this album better than ANATO because of its structure/continuity, but in terms of songs I think no song of DSOTM can reach the excellence of 'Bohemian Rhapsody'. |
| Poo, again 01.03.2007 14:04 |
Nothing can compare to Queen II. |
| Matias Merçeauroix 01.03.2007 16:01 |
<font color=pink>Account Deleted wrote: Nothing can compare to Queen II.at least not led zeppeshit |
| blerp 01.03.2007 20:30 |
Valensian Sky Surveillance wrote::(<font color=pink>Account Deleted wrote: Nothing can compare to Queen II.at least not led zeppeshit |
| Lester Burnham 01.03.2007 21:05 |
The Who. |
| Oszmercury 02.03.2007 00:23 |
Valensian Sky Surveillance wrote:Agree, but mmm Kashmir, Stairway to Heaven, Achilles last stand and When the levee breaks, you can go wrong with them, tha's class and rock and roll<font color=pink>Account Deleted wrote: Nothing can compare to Queen II.at least not led zeppeshit |
| Saif 02.03.2007 00:55 |
Oszmercury wrote:I think the best songs of LZ are Immigrant Song, Since I've Been Loving You, Whole Lotta Love, Black Dog and Babe I'm Gonna Leave You.Valensian Sky Surveillance wrote:Agree, but mmm Kashmir, Stairway to Heaven, Achilles last stand and When the levee breaks, you can go wrong with them, tha's class and rock and roll<font color=pink>Account Deleted wrote: Nothing can compare to Queen II.at least not led zeppeshit |
| Matias Merçeauroix 02.03.2007 01:32 |
Some primitive rock n roll songs are better than Queen II? If so, we're really fucked up. Come on!! Black Dog one of the best LZ songs??? it's a shitty song, The Battle Of Evermore is 98461298736498127629384 times better!!! |
| Saif 02.03.2007 01:40 |
Well I guess it's because I prefer their Funk-Rock songs...but "Battle of Evermore" is awesome too... |
| its_a_hard_life 26994 02.03.2007 09:26 |
Lester Burnham wrote: The Who.:-DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD. |
| deleted user 03.03.2007 21:22 |
Queen's better, but Zeppelin's a VERY close 2nd. As for the debut albums, I've always considered Queen to be a very weak start for them, whereas Led Zeppelin is very good with a great representation of their overall style. |
| john bodega 03.03.2007 22:45 |
Lester Burnham wrote: The Who.You call THAT a bargain? |
| The Real Wizard 04.03.2007 00:56 |
Sparrow wrote: funny you ask im wearing a zeppelin t-shirt right now!Haha, me too! |
| RETROLOVE 06.03.2007 01:46 |
I couldnt choose, I like em both! |