I like him best because he seems like the only one who actually gives useful advice, even if the useful advice is "Put down the microphone and step away verrrry slowly". :D
His taste in music sucks. Fuck him. He says that Bob Dylan sucks compared to Kelly Clarkson. Yeah, a man whose tastes encompass musicians in the same vein of untalented bitches like Alanis Morissette, Coldplay, Britney Spears, Mariah Carey, Celine Dion, etc(PS: fuck them too)...sure, he's awesome. *rolls eyes* His musical taste sucks but other than that he's on okay judge. As if ANY of the contestants are good anyway. The winners suck just as bad...
hey, he's the best thing that happened to American Idol!!!! he makes it more funny!! but last nights episode with that one guy who sang amazing grace....wow that was bad!!!
<font color="FF00CC">Helter Skelter wrote: Well, the fact that he dissed "Innuendo" last year makes me sort of dislike him...but as a critic - I guess he's OKAY.
<font color="FF00CC">Helter Skelter wrote: Well, the fact that he dissed "Innuendo" last year makes me sort of dislike him...but as a critic - I guess he's OKAY.
I know, that totally pissed me off last year!
Yeah , I agree.
His taste of music sucks , since it seems to me , he does not appreciate Queen' music .
Actually I love to watch American Idol ,and as a judge he's okay .
But I can tell he does not appreciate Queen and its music by his comments every time some one try to sing Queen songs .
Simon , as an Brit , your taste of music really sucks ...sucks ...
Here in Spain there's a program similar to AI called "Operacion Triunfo". And now they copied the "Bad judge" version, but this one is very silly, I prefer Simon :P
Saif wrote: His taste in music sucks. Fuck him. He says that Bob Dylan sucks compared to Kelly Clarkson.
...but Bob Dylan sucks as a singer. Let alone comparing him to Kelly Clarkson.
Can you picture Bob Dylan auditioning?
He would be one of the highlights of the early season rejects.
<font color="FF00CC">Helter Skelter wrote: Well, the fact that he dissed "Innuendo" last year makes me sort of dislike him...but as a critic - I guess he's OKAY.
I know, that totally pissed me off last year!
Yeah me too. I thought Chris Daughtrey did a great job.
kimmithee wrote: Does anyone in here like him on American Idol? Alot of people say he's an idiot or a jackass. what do you think?
He's the idiot who said Innuendo wasn't a very good song. Then goes on and lists acts like 5ive and crap as his biggest achievements in the music biz.
deleted user 18.02.2007 11:13
Mr.Jingles wrote:
Saif wrote: His taste in music sucks. Fuck him. He says that Bob Dylan sucks compared to Kelly Clarkson.
...but Bob Dylan sucks as a singer. Let alone comparing him to Kelly Clarkson.
Can you picture Bob Dylan auditioning?
He would be one of the highlights of the early season rejects.