QueenZone discussion #793853

queen singers

queenfan4eva
30.05.2006 09:17		 hey guys me again which 1 of these rock singers should replace the late Freddie mercury
1. Justin Hawkins band: the darkness
2. Roger daltrey band: the who
3. James hetfield band: metallica
4. Robert plant band: led zeppelin
5.Axl rose band: gun N roses
6. Joe Elliot band: def leppard
7. Gary cherone band: extreme
8. Ian hunter band: Mott the hoople
9. Eddie vanhalen band: vanhalen
10. David cover dale band: white snake
11. Joe Perry band: aero smith
12.Bruce Dickson band: iron maiden
13. Brain Johnson band: ac dc
14.Paul Rodgers band: free
15.Paul McCartney band: the Beatles
16. Glenn Hughes band: black Sabbath
17. Eric clapton band: cream
18. Roger Taylor band: the cross
19. Brain may band: the brain may band
20 Gene Simmons band: kiss
21Rob Hal ford band: Judas priest
22. Adrian belew band: king crimson
23 Jon Anderson band: yes
24. Eric bloom band: blue oyster cult
25. John wetton band: Asia
26. Chris Cornell band: sound garden
27. David glamour band: pink Floyd
28. Steve win wood band: traffic
29. Ricky Phillips band: Styx
30. Robert palmer band: power station
Poo, again
30.05.2006 10:07		 Freddie can't be replaced.
flash! 28068
30.05.2006 10:08
<font color=pink>The Millionaire Waltz wrote: Freddie can't be replaced.
Agreed.
FreMe
30.05.2006 10:49		 Ey! You forgot Reneé Diff from Aqua! lol :p
Carol! the Musical
30.05.2006 11:25
<font color=red>Flash! wrote:
<font color=pink>The Millionaire Waltz wrote: Freddie can't be replaced.
Agreed.
Freddie can't be replaced. But Freddie, can. :p
Micrówave
30.05.2006 11:27		 I say Eddie Van Halen, from your list. I hear he's got a great voice these days. Maybe he could bring his "Jump" keyboards with him.
Then again, maybe not.
Queen_Rox
30.05.2006 11:47
<font color=red>Flash! wrote:
<font color=pink>The Millionaire Waltz wrote: Freddie can't be replaced.
Agreed.
Ditto.
deleted user
30.05.2006 15:48
queenfan4eva wrote: hey guys me again which 1 of these rock singers should replace the late Freddie mercury
learn how to spell as i dont know any Freddie Merucrys.....
deaconMTY
30.05.2006 16:08		 robert palmer is dead
gem27
30.05.2006 17:16		 Robert Palmer??? hadn't you heard, he is also dead so he would have one hell of a job.
Sherwood Forest
30.05.2006 17:17		 freddie mercury ?
bonnzzo
30.05.2006 17:45		 Seriously though, nobody can replace Freddie but if you are talking about who could sing for them after he died, I still say George Michael was the best option after all the hype he and the boys had after the Concert for Life (Somebody to Love), but that was around his Listen Without Pregudice time period and the stars weren't alinged just right...
louvox
30.05.2006 17:56		 Can't be replaced
deleted user
30.05.2006 18:06
queenfan4eva wrote: hey guys me again which 1 of these rock singers should replace the late Freddie mercury 1. Justin Hawkins band: the darkness 2. Roger daltrey band: the who 3. James hetfield band: metallica 4. Robert plant band: led zeppelin 5.Axl rose band: gun N roses 6. Joe Elliot band: def leppard 7. Gary cherone band: extreme 8. Ian hunter band: Mott the hoople 9. Eddie vanhalen band: vanhalen 10. David cover dale band: white snake 11. Joe Perry band: aero smith 12.Bruce Dickson band: iron maiden 13. Brain Johnson band: ac dc 14.Paul Rodgers band: free 15.Paul McCartney band: the Beatles 16. Glenn Hughes band: black Sabbath 17. Eric clapton band: cream 18. Roger Taylor band: the cross 19. Brain may band: the brain may band 20 Gene Simmons band: kiss 21Rob Hal ford band: Judas priest 22. Adrian belew band: king crimson 23 Jon Anderson band: yes 24. Eric bloom band: blue oyster cult 25. John wetton band: Asia 26. Chris Cornell band: sound garden 27. David glamour band: pink Floyd 28. Steve win wood band: traffic 29. Ricky Phillips band: Styx 30. Robert palmer band: power station
You list David Gilmour but not Roger Waters, who was arguably more important?
deleted user
30.05.2006 18:39
<font color=pink>The Millionaire Waltz wrote: Freddie can't be replaced.
DOUBLE DOULBE TRIPLE AGREED NO-ONE!>-:(
deleted user
30.05.2006 18:39
<font color=heart>EmpressOfTheUniverse wrote:
queenfan4eva wrote: hey guys me again which 1 of these rock singers should replace the late Freddie mercury
learn how to spell as i dont know any Freddie Merucrys.....
Freddie Mercury mate!
AmeriQueen
31.05.2006 02:22		 1. Justin Hawkins band: the darkness
The fact that you mention him first disturbs me. There are singers who simply don't have a good voice, then there is this gimp, one who's style is an absolute perfection of musical shit, maximizing his ability to use his voice at it's worst possible level. The guy seems truly gifted at singing in such an originally horrid way, difficult for one to top in attempting to sound like shit. The Darkness is truly worst than anything I have ever come across, not that I would totally know considering my 100% effort to change any station playing their vomit songs.
2. Roger daltrey band: the who
I don't think the Who come near Queen, and I think Daltrey is their biggest weakness.
3. James hetfield band: metallica
He could do as many as maybe 7 or 8(tops) Queen songs pretty well, but none near Freddie.
4. Robert plant band: led zeppelin
Not realistic, but would be a mismatch.
5.Axl rose band: gun N roses
See Robert Plant
6. Joe Elliot band: def leppard
Great for some songs, not ideal though.
7. Gary cherone band: extreme
Yeah Right!
8. Ian hunter band: Mott the hoople
? Too weird to consider.
9. Eddie vanhalen band: vanhalen
I assume you mean Roth or Hagar, not that it makes any difference in answer.
10. David cover dale band: white snake
I would be very curious to see the results because I like him alot. That being said... Next.
11. Joe Perry band: aero smith
You mean Tyler? Could nail a few, not a good or realistic choice worth considering.
12.Bruce Dickson band: iron maiden
Good singer, but is on an opposite style than Queen.
13. Brain Johnson band: ac dc
Yeab Right.
14.Paul Rodgers band: free
Shockingly strong, I have no complaints. We have a winner.
15.Paul McCartney band: the Beatles
Not realistic, but would do well I am sure.
16. Glenn Hughes band: black Sabbath
Who??
17. Eric clapton band: cream
Nothing like Queen
18. Roger Taylor band: the cross
I'd live with it.
19. Brain may band: the brain may band
Same as Roger
20 Gene Simmons band: kiss
You mean Stanley. HORRIBLE IDEA.
21Rob Hal ford band: Judas priest
Could nail 4 or 5 songs, would be a ridiculous choice for the rest.
22. Adrian belew band: king crimson
?
23 Jon Anderson band: yes
YUCK!
24. Eric bloom band: blue oyster cult
?
25. John wetton band: Asia
?
26. Chris Cornell band: sound garden
Interesting possiblility.
27. David glamour band: pink Floyd
Yuck!
28. Steve win wood band: traffic
Triple Yuck!
29. Ricky Phillips band: Styx
Dude, get the singers right. Dennis De Young or Tommy Shaw. Both would be mediocre replacements for the job.
30. Robert palmer band: power station
Same problem as Freddie, he's dead. Wouldn't work anyway.
Beyond Paul, George Michael is an obvious Freddie imitation, Rufus Wainright is my determined answer to the problem.
I will say once again, 'Millionare Waltz' was made for Rufus!