| icefire 23.01.2006 07:46 |
link what do you think?? are they making fun of freddie sticking that tape as a mustache???? |
| Mr Drowse 23.01.2006 08:06 |
I'd rather see it as a tribute. I think it 's funny. Greenday rock! |
| Sherwood Forest 23.01.2006 11:23 |
i think they make the song worse than it is |
| Hippolyte 23.01.2006 15:04 |
Green Day does a good job with it and this is a cover version I actually like. There's much worse bands who have done or could be doing Queen songs. |
| Monte: Liquorice Years 23.01.2006 21:28 |
In an interview ages ago with Billie Joe Armstrong, he said that Queen were a major influence for their American Idiot album. He also said that Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming (the two 9-minute long songs on the album) were their Bohemian Rhapsody. Or something along those lines. I think it's sweet that they sung 'We Are The Champions' as a tribute. And Billie Joe is the original Sex On Legs, making it so much better. |
| jchensf 23.01.2006 22:23 |
Also, if you watch the GD Bible in a Bullet DVD, Billie Joe says that this is the first opportunity that they have ever had to play in front of HUGE stadium sized crowds. He wanted to do something SPECTACULAR that was beyond just a fireworks show. He wanted to make it intimate, but also wanted everyone to see something memorable. It is a fine tribute to Queen done with PUNK respect. He certainly doesn't sing it like Queen, but the crowd was certainly with him and he made it memorable. Don't mind the tape in the beginning it was BJ just fooling around. I remember seeing GD when they were playing Sunday afternoons to just 30 people at Gilman Street in Berkeley, CA. -- Jim |
| Music Man 24.01.2006 00:50 |
I never realized how poorly his stage voice is until this video. In fact, at several points during the video, during the non-chorus parts (the choruses were pretty good), he could be clearly mistaken as mentally handicapped or suffering from some other disability. I enjoy much of Green Day's studio work, but this was disappointing. |
| J B 24.01.2006 01:23 |
i cant stand Green Day *~* |
| magicalfreddiemercury 24.01.2006 09:41 |
Okay, sorry, I couldn't get through the whole song. Don't think I like Green Day. BUT... I thought it was interesting when he removed his mustache. Did you notice? It was right after he said, "and bad mistakes". Then he held it up for a second and said, "I've made a few". Poor Freddie. The world will always remember his mustache-acceptance woes. Guess it was a playful tribute. |
| YlvaDaJackass 25.01.2006 11:52 |
I like the idea of atribute, but I think Billie Joe sang it horrible. He ruined the whole song. But, sure, if it's a tribute to Queen then I can accept it. |
| blerp 25.01.2006 16:40 |
I don't like Green Day. I like their early-90s stuff, but when I heard Billie Joe sing WATC at Live 8, it was like someone was scraping a fork and knife on a plate right next to me. :) |
| YlvaDaJackass 26.01.2006 08:44 |
LadyMercury wrote: it was like someone was scraping a fork and knife on a plate right next to me. :)Exactly. |
| Sherwood Forest 26.01.2006 12:47 |
LadyMercury wrote: I don't like Green Day. I like their early-90s stuff, but when I heard Billie Joe sing WATC at Live 8, it was like someone was scraping a fork and knife on a plate right next to me. :)EXACTLY how i felt, i watched that pissing my pants laughing at them, then everyone's like they stole the preformance with that song i was like ummmm no one even listens to Queen on this network do they? then when i saw them playing red special i was like yea this really is not right. I actually got yelled at from my mom cuz i was laughying so hard |
| ~-:Moet et Chandon:-~ 27.01.2006 11:27 |
WHOAH...hold on hold on...Green Day played the Red Special?? |
| icefire 27.01.2006 12:45 |
only a replica of it of course!!! Brian would have killed them for touching his one..lol |
| YlvaDaJackass 27.01.2006 13:23 |
OMG, that so lame, how could they do that??? Play "a" Red-Special, that's horrible. |
| NJQueenFan 27.01.2006 13:54 |
GD can go suck a dick, god they kill that song every time |
| greaserkat 27.01.2006 21:58 |
Ive seen a picture from their past tour or present tour where I guess its at the end of the concert, Billy Is in the front of the stage with a crown and a robe exactly as that of Freddie when he came out during the Magic Tour at the end of the concerts. I think that sucks cause first he killed WATC by singing it and now he's killing one of Freddie's greatest moments during Queen's tours. |
| Music Man 28.01.2006 03:33 |
Green Day isn't killing anything. It'll take more than a B-list band to kill the legacy of Queen. |
| Hooligan's Holiday 28.01.2006 10:40 |
J B wrote: i cant stand Green Day *~*ditto. x~x |
| YlvaDaJackass 28.01.2006 12:49 |
What's wrong with them?? What is their fucking problem??? Can't they come up with something own, instead of copying Queen all the time?? Apparently not.... >:( |
| Exchange . 28.01.2006 17:16 |
OMG! GOD I HATE GREEN DAY! THEIR FUCKING QUEEN WANNABES! IT'S A INSULT TO QUEEN!! |
| jcrawford79 28.01.2006 18:29 |
YlvaDaJackass wrote: What's wrong with them?? What is their fucking problem??? Can't they come up with something own, instead of copying Queen all the time?? Apparently not.... >:(Copying Queen all the time?? Certainly the most unfounded statement I've ever heard, Green Day fan or not. |
| maxpower 28.01.2006 19:18 |
having just watched it - its fine they did a good job ... far better that stupid bitch Liza Menelli at Freddie's tribute show (that still makes me cringe) |
| PinkInk 28.01.2006 19:45 |
Green Day isn't one of my favorites , i thought they did WATC horribly :\ |
| YlvaDaJackass 28.01.2006 19:58 |
jcrawford79 wrote:Haha :)YlvaDaJackass wrote: What's wrong with them?? What is their fucking problem??? Can't they come up with something own, instead of copying Queen all the time?? Apparently not.... >:(Copying Queen all the time?? Certainly the most unfounded statement I've ever heard, Green Day fan or not. Playing WATC, playing a red-special-copy, coming out on stage with a crone and a cape, SAYING THEMSELVES that their American Idiot-album is mainly influenced by Queen, calling their f*cking Jesus of Subrubia-song "a Bo Rhap". If you (like Green Day) have done all these things I find it only fair of me to say "copying Queen all the time" :) (well... you know 'all the time', it's what I say...) |
| deleted user 29.01.2006 06:50 |
I know this girl and she thought that WATC was a greenday song.... When I told her that it was QUEEN. She said Queen were better then she thought... |
| icefire 29.01.2006 07:00 |
well i do not seem to hate greed day..they do their own stuff in their own style rather okay..they know how to entertain-that's what they do good..and all the stuff with queen should be taken as a tribute..better or worse but a tribute-that is a good promotional thing i think..don't you?? |
| rachael mae. 29.01.2006 07:22 |
I thought it was pretty awesome, and not at all insulting. |