Never had the opportunity to hear either until after the MIH album, and the web providing the availability to purchase back in the stone ages.
For my 'best of' chronological Cross hits CD, Freddie's LV version is perfect after 'Rough Justice' and 50 some seconds of an ending instrumental of 'Shove It'. The Roger LV extended version after 'Life Changes' makes for a great final track.
I love them both for different reasons.