Hi Everyone
was scouring the blu ray shelves in HMV today
and found the Rock Montreal bluray with Commentary by roger and brian, i was wondering if anyone had this and had any comments about it??
Cheers guys
David
oliverd05 wrote:
Hi Everyone
was scouring the blu ray shelves in HMV today
and found the Rock Montreal bluray with Commentary by roger and brian, i was wondering if anyone had this and had any comments about it??
Cheers guys
David
To be honest, it's a bit underwhelming
Save your money of you already have it on DVD without the commentary
the best looking / sounding Queen live release there is, and ever will be. if that's remotely important to you, get it NOW.
the commentary is nice enough, certainly as a bonus feature. wish they had done it for the other dvds
it is interesting to hear how Brian and Roger didn't really like Freddie's shorts - "not his best look" - I think they both agreed. And it is kinda funny to hear about how difficult it was working with the film crew but then later they point out the excellent cinematography!
I found it interesting enough, though not super in-depth.
They talk a lot about their disdain for director Saul Swimmer and how the concert film came about, which becomes of even more interest if you have the earlier We Will Rock You DVD release of the same film, which has a commentary by Swimmer himself. Swimmer is very complimentary of group and their working relationship all around. He talks in greater detail of the technical aspects of the shooting, editing and the band's involvement during and after, in post-production. From his commentary, you wouldn't know there had been any bad blood between them, so when I heard Brian and Roger tell their side of the story, it was a bit jarring that they were so venomous towards him. I'm not saying it wasn't justified, I'm sure the band honestly felt that way, but compare that to Swimmer's approach (right or wrong) to not speak ill of the subjects of his film, even years later, and you see two contrasting views of the same project from the people who were there.