| popy 05.05.2011 04:47 |
If it was released on Blu-Ray, with the full first night concert, with the second night fully avaible in multicam and with a new audio mix, will you buy it? And what more would you include on this release? I've sayd a new audio mix because when the DVD was released in 2003, if i remember, the 5.1 mix is an upmix of the stereo mix since, at the time of the release, they didn't have the multis. But in the Bohemian Rhapsody Rock Band 3 video link the mix is different. Maybe they do now have the multis. Is that true? |
| dysan 05.05.2011 05:26 |
I'd get it if they took that bad 80's flange effect off the guitar. It's not so noticable on Live Magic. |
| cmsdrums 05.05.2011 08:44 |
If they can go back to the multi track audio tapes and remix the sound properly (rather than, as you say, upmix from the existing stereo) then yes, I would buy it. The guitar especially needs thickening up, although I recall a post here years ago saying that Brian was trying out a new set up/effect then which may not be able to be removed (God knows why he'd choose to do it for the first time on a recorded gig though!) Montreal sounds superb, but I still think that the MK Bowl audio is messy, and not a particulalry great job when they boast about how much work they did on that going back to the master tapes (levelling up the electronic drum sounds to the acoustic drums etc..) - shame after all that the snare sounds poor and the kick has no 'oomph' or clarity. |
| john bodega 05.05.2011 12:39 |
Not sure if I'd buy it. Given the quality of the source itself (video instead of film) I don't think there'd be much to gain. Unless they want to throw on a heap more stuff that we don't have already, I wouldn't be buying it. At this point in time, I only have eyes for 70's gigs. And GVH3. Everything else can just fuck off. |
| Hangman2011 05.05.2011 12:54 |
what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's |
| emrabt 05.05.2011 13:17 |
what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ====================== Let me guess, you are ANOTHER goodoldfashionedloverboy account? |
| Hangman2011 05.05.2011 13:28 |
emrabt wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ====================== Let me guess, you are ANOTHER goodoldfashionedloverboy account? No, I do not know goodoldfashioned loverboy |
| pittrek 05.05.2011 13:36 |
It was filmed on VIDEO, and NOT on FILM => it can't be "properly" transferred to BluRay |
| Rick 05.05.2011 14:20 |
cmsdrums wrote: If they can go back to the multi track audio tapes and remix the sound properly (rather than, as you say, upmix from the existing stereo) then yes, I would buy it. The guitar especially needs thickening up, although I recall a post here years ago saying that Brian was trying out a new set up/effect then which may not be able to be removed (God knows why he'd choose to do it for the first time on a recorded gig though!) Montreal sounds superb, but I still think that the MK Bowl audio is messy, and not a particulalry great job when they boast about how much work they did on that going back to the master tapes (levelling up the electronic drum sounds to the acoustic drums etc..) - shame after all that the snare sounds poor and the kick has no 'oomph' or clarity. -------------------------- Agreed. MK audio is really bad. The guitar, bass and Freddie himself sound ace, the rest is really mediocre. I have always hated the drum sound on this release. The original broadcast is much better: link Also, the backing vocals are really low in the mix. You can barely hear Roger during Action This Day and Somebody To Love, for example. On Rock Montreal the vocals are more balanced and the overal sound is much better. It still misses a certain live feeling, though. Is this mix of Wembley really new? I haven't listened to it for a while. |
| popy 05.05.2011 15:07 |
It's one thing i forgot to add in my first post. I know it's video, but with an Blu-Ray release, it will have far higher bitrate. By the time the DVD was released, big LCD's were not widely available. Now if someone watches the DVD in a LCD, the low bitrate that the DVD is encoded (rarely going beyond 2,5Mbps) is very noticeable (very pixellated), even in LCD pc monitors. So my thought about a possible Wembley Blu-Ray: 1- Far higher image bitrate 2- Full first night 3- Full second night in multicam 4- New audio remixed from multitracks (if they have them) 5- Search the vaults and make a comprehensive full length documentary about the Magic Tour, not just Wembley. What more would you add to this? I just want to hear your ideas. Of course i'm also waiting for 70's concerts on DVD and GVH3, i'm just curious about what more could be done for an hypothetical Wembley Blu-Ray release. |
| Thistle 05.05.2011 15:11 |
Hangman2011 wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ============================================================================================= Despite what you say, you ARE GOFLB, as only he would talk like that. In answer to the question, it probably wouldn't look any better so no, I wouldn't buy it. |
| Hangman2011 05.05.2011 22:42 |
Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ============================================================================================= Despite what you say, you ARE GOFLB, as only he would talk like that. In answer to the question, it probably wouldn't look any better so no, I wouldn't buy it. Honestly, you are mistaken,really |
| Thistle 06.05.2011 13:30 |
Hangman2011 wrote: Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ============================================================================================= Despite what you say, you ARE GOFLB, as only he would talk like that. In answer to the question, it probably wouldn't look any better so no, I wouldn't buy it. Honestly, you are mistaken,really ============================================================================================= Well, sorry if you're not - it's just that he is the only person on planet earth who would say "what a fuck....want concerts '70s", and you've only just appeared shortly after he was deleted. I'm not convinced.... |
| YannickJoker 06.05.2011 13:55 |
Idiots... Anyway, I wouldn't buy it because as others have pointed out, it was filmed on video, so only artificial enhancement could make it bigger and it would still be 4:3. |
| Thistle 06.05.2011 17:16 |
YannickJoker wrote: Idiots... ============================================================================================= Care to elaborate? |
| brians wig 06.05.2011 20:48 |
Just to have it at the full 625 line resolution and the highest bitrate possible to avoid nay arteacts, you're damn right I'd buy it. People need to start realising that "Bluray" isn't just for HD material - it can be used to greater storage capacity and therefore SD material should look EXACTLY the same as the master tapes.... |
| Hangman2011 07.05.2011 04:47 |
Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ============================================================================================= Despite what you say, you ARE GOFLB, as only he would talk like that. In answer to the question, it probably wouldn't look any better so no, I wouldn't buy it. Honestly, you are mistaken,really ============================================================================================= Well, sorry if you're not - it's just that he is the only person on planet earth who would say "what a fuck....want concerts '70s", and you've only just appeared shortly after he was deleted. I'm not convinced.... ================================================================================================ It is your right to be convinced. I'm not going to make excuses, but I blurted word "fuck" out against my will. Do you have nothing else to do in life? Do you like to humiliate and insult users? I am more than confident that user Goodoldfashionedloverboy was deleted only because someone decided he was from Russia and he spoke English badly. There are some users with poor English on this forum but no-one's that slighted and insulted. |
| Hangman2011 07.05.2011 05:20 |
Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: Thistleboy 1980 wrote: Hangman2011 wrote: what a fuck blu ray? want concerts 70's ============================================================================================= Despite what you say, you ARE GOFLB, as only he would talk like that. In answer to the question, it probably wouldn't look any better so no, I wouldn't buy it. Honestly, you are mistaken,really ============================================================================================= Well, sorry if you're not - it's just that he is the only person on planet earth who would say "what a fuck....want concerts '70s", and you've only just appeared shortly after he was deleted. I'm not convinced.... ================================================================================================ Do you care about my nickname? Do you judge the man by a nickname? You still say that nickname "Goodoldfashionedloverboy" is a shadow of homosexuality. |
| Thistle 10.05.2011 16:50 |
@Hangman 2011 I never insulted you, never once mentioned Russia or poor English or even insinuated that GOFLB = homosexuality. I am really confused as to how you managed to reach such thoughts. |
| brians wig 10.05.2011 17:31 |
pittrek wrote: It was filmed on VIDEO, and NOT on FILM => it can't be "properly" transferred to BluRay -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Bluray, like DVD, is a storage vehicle, not a 'format'. There are plenty of "Official" Bluray discs on the market that contain mpeg2 video files but at much higher bitrates than found on DVD. |
| johnnyrock 11.02.2014 16:22 |
to be honest if a blu ray was released that just had what the dvd had on it (which I assume they'll rescan for the higher resolution of blu ray) I'd buy it. I have a big collection of blu rays and it seems odd that the Wembley concert was rereleased with two dvds and two cds but not on blu ray like the live in Budapest blu ray was. I'd love to see the blu ray come out the same way with the cds included. I am a huge Queen fan and have the remastered 2011 cds, and it would be a shame if this live show, one of the best live shows of any band hands down, doesn't get the full blu ray treatment. Maybe add some current interviews with the surviving members looking back. maybe a scrapbook-like slide show too (with a musical background). This should have already been released though especially since they re-released the dvd (I am holding off on the new version (I still have the old version) until I am 100% sure there isn't going to be a blu ray release. But I have my fingers crossed. |
| Pingfah 12.02.2014 03:56 |
I might. I would rather have 70s concerts on Blu Ray though, and a Blu Ray package of GVH 1 through 3. |