| guesswho2 03.01.2011 19:55 |
This "upgrade" differs from the previous upload in a couple of ways. There is no short "edit" during "It's A Hard Life". There is extra footage which features brief rehearsal material and different camera angles for "It's A Hard Life" and "We Will Rock You". Queen - Prince's Trust - 17th November 2010 Source : Sky Digital Broadcast Captured : Downscaled by Panasonic Standalone DVD recorder to make DVD compatible. Picture : PAL 16:9 (Widescreen) 25fp/s 720x576 Around 8Mbps Sound : Dolby Digital 2.0 384 kbps (Stereo) Lineage : Sky Digital > Panasonic DVDR > PC > DVD Chaptered menued and authored using TMPGenc4 1.These Are the Days of Our Lives 2.Last Horizon 3.It's A Hard Life 4.Seven Seas Of Rhye 5.We Will Rock You 6.Rehearsal Footage 7.It's A Hard Life - Different camera angles 8.We Will Rock You - Different camera angles Menu link |
| guesswho2 03.01.2011 19:59 |
. |
| Marknow 03.01.2011 20:07 |
Thank you for this upgrade, you should have made the audio LPCM(lossless), Dolby 2.0 or AC3 is a compressed(lossy) format. Is it too late to fix it? |
| guesswho2 03.01.2011 20:32 |
My source from Sky HD box doesn't allow me to access the LPCM audio when I transfer to the standalone DVD so unfortunately you are correct in saying the audio could be technically better.....however having watched the DVD and compared it to the original broadcast I can't hear any difference.....then again my hearing may be shot!!! (Also having made some home DVDs with LPCM audio....I've noticed that the bitrate for the video is reduced to cope with the increase in the audio bitrate so in a way it's a trade off with more info going into the picture which hopefully is worth it) |
| Marknow 03.01.2011 21:13 |
Ah right, thanks for explaining, as you said it's not much of a differance anyway. The video will be well worth it. LPCM would not have affected your bitrate btw, it caps at 8.5Mbs. Thanks again. |
| Ale Solan 03.01.2011 22:03 |
thank you both guesswho2 & Mark for sharing both versions! cheers! |
| brians wig 03.01.2011 23:12 |
Thanks for this. How come there's no short edit during Hard Life? Surely the HD and SD Broadcasts were the same? |
| Marknow 04.01.2011 01:08 |
Anyone else see some distracting green lines or dots across the top of the video in full screen mode, or do I have a codec problem? |
| MarkRW 04.01.2011 01:22 |
Thank you. |
| guesswho2 04.01.2011 02:28 |
Marknow wrote: Anyone else see some distracting green lines or dots across the top of the video in full screen mode, or do I have a codec problem? ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................... When watching on PC you will see these green lines which I believe are due to the fact that you will be seeing all the lines of the picture (ie 625) however on most TVs these will not be seen because the first few lines of the picture are generally hidden (unless you have manually altered the proportions of the image displayed in a service menu). |
| Vali 04.01.2011 03:49 |
great share ! many thanks ! |
| Hitman 04.01.2011 05:07 |
oh thank you for sharing this video! |
| brians wig 04.01.2011 06:37 |
Marknow wrote: Thank you for this upgrade, you should have made the audio LPCM(lossless), Dolby 2.0 or AC3 is a compressed(lossy) format. Is it too late to fix it? -------------------------------------------------------- Just so that everyone is aware, neither Sky nor Freesat broadcasts an LPCM soundtrack - it takes up far too much bandwidth. All video streams are encoded with an AC3 soundtrack - even on the HD channels. |
| pittrek 04.01.2011 06:52 |
Hey, thanks |
| Rami 04.01.2011 08:04 |
Thank you very much!! |
| Bo Alex 04.01.2011 11:33 |
Thank you!!! |
| Marknow 04.01.2011 11:57 |
brians wig wrote: Marknow wrote: Thank you for this upgrade, you should have made the audio LPCM(lossless), Dolby 2.0 or AC3 is a compressed(lossy) format. Is it too late to fix it? -------------------------------------------------------- Just so that everyone is aware, neither Sky nor Freesat broadcasts an LPCM soundtrack - it takes up far too much bandwidth. All video streams are encoded with an AC3 soundtrack - even on the HD channels. _____________________________________________________________________________________________ It does not matter if sky broadcast in mp3 or morse code. LPCM would have given a lossless copy of the sky audio stream, instead of this compressed lossy version. People record in Wav for a reason you know. BTW the green line does not bother you at all? A one second blip on my share was VERY distressing for you, but you seem to have dropped your standards for this share. Why is that Dave? |
| guesswho2 04.01.2011 12:16 |
I seem to have stirred up bit of ill-feeling here regading the audio on this DVD. I always try to provide the best quality DVD I can but am no expert. My hope is that people can enjoy the DVD for what it is....a home-produced version of an HD transmission. |
| Marknow 04.01.2011 12:41 |
@ guesswhotoo You did the best job possible with the equipment you have, no question of it. |
| brians wig 04.01.2011 12:54 |
Marknow wrote: It does not matter if sky broadcast in mp3 or morse code. LPCM would have given a lossless copy of the sky audio stream, instead of this compressed lossy version. People record in Wav for a reason you know. BTW the green line does not bother you at all? A one second blip on my share was VERY distressing for you, but you seem to have dropped your standards for this share. Why is that Dave? ----------------------------------------- Okay. #1. You can't make a lossless recording from a lossy stream and I simply aimed to make people aware of the fact that the broadcast was not lossless in the first place, and nothing more. #2: If the remainder of your response is aimed at me, firstly I've downloaded neither version and therefore have made no comment on the "blip" nor have I seen this green line..... |
| TimBHM 04.01.2011 12:57 |
Thanks! |
| bigV 04.01.2011 16:17 |
Great! Now if some kind soul would be gracious enough to make us a nice DVD cover that would be amazing! :) V. |
| bigV 04.01.2011 16:39 |
Wow... I just caught on to Brian's faux pas. "It's a Hard Life has probably never been performed live".... How embarrassing... Oooops, right? V. |
| Hitman 04.01.2011 17:38 |
bigV wrote: Great! Now if some kind soul would be gracious enough to make us a nice DVD cover that would be amazing! :) V. i subscribe this kind request of the friend bigV ;) artists of Queenzone it's your turn!! |
| DragonOnMyBack 05.01.2011 07:00 |
BigV, With reference to Brian's faux pas, he also said on the night when introducing Seas of Rhye that they had not played it since about 1974, although that was cut from the TV broadcast along with the some other comments about it being Midges fault if they mess it up becuase they had not played it for so long. |
| DragonOnMyBack 05.01.2011 07:04 |
brians wig wrote: Thanks for this. How come there's no short edit during Hard Life? Surely the HD and SD Broadcasts were the same? There was some additional concert footage shown in the 1/2 hour programme (containing rehersal footage / interviews etc) shown on Sky Arts straight after the main broadcast. |
| deleted user 05.01.2011 11:10 |
Thanks for sharing this. Nice menu and the green line is not visible on my TV. Good work. |
| gaspar 05.01.2011 11:21 |
|
| LeroyB74 06.01.2011 04:39 |
The version of "It's a hard life" by Tom Chaplin made me cry. One of the greatest queen covers i have heard in my life. |
| tgunn2760 10.01.2011 08:43 |
Thank you! |
| Double-U 11.01.2011 02:51 |
Finally I managed to watch this version last night. Thank you for this upgrade with the bonus section. You rock and so do Marknow kind regards W. |
| ziggybsas 17.01.2011 08:09 |
great upload!!!! any cover for this????? |
| indyclev 21.01.2011 07:35 |
Thanks for this edit, much appreciated |
| queenside 29.01.2011 14:29 |
alex can you make an artwork for this great share? |
| tassilo 09.03.2011 11:21 |
Once again: Thank you! |
| tonyyy 16.04.2011 04:37 |
Thanks a lot! Tony My webpage: link |
