Ale Solan 30.05.2007 01:18 |
If he's related with Dylan Thomas he can't be that crappy. Right? Diss Cus--> link |
The Fairy King 30.05.2007 06:33 |
Bob Dylan is poopy. |
thomasquinn 32989 30.05.2007 07:44 |
Dylan Thomas is better than Bob Dylan, there's no doubt about that...but Dylan is an ace songwriter, a very good arranger (only Raf will deny this, but then again, he also thinks that The Edge is a good guitarist...), and occasionally even a good singer ("Like A Rolling Stone", "Percy's Song", "The Lonesome Death Of Hatty Carroll" to name but three songs). Just too bad that he's not a very nice person, because he's certainly a great artist! |
deleted user 30.05.2007 11:12 |
BOb Dylan has written some amazing songs. He's not a very good singer, though (proof of this can be found in the fact that many of his songs have gone on and achieved greater success being covered). And I don't know about him as a person. Is he supposed to be nice? Or really really mean? |
deleted user 30.05.2007 11:58 |
I don't believe in Zimmerman, I just believe in me. |
***Marial-B*** 30.05.2007 13:32 |
<b><font color="#FF1493">The Fairy King wrote: Bob Dylan is poopy.That's why I made the first thread, this is a copycat thread -.-' |
.DeaconJohn. 30.05.2007 13:51 |
I'm a massive fan. I have to say that Hurricane is also a great vocal performance from him IMHO. I don't see how anyone could sing that song as convincingly as Bob. |
Ale Solan 30.05.2007 21:55 |
<font color="magenta">Marial-B wrote:Smirnoff to wash your mouth at morning is not good for you, Caro.<b><font color="#FF1493">The Fairy King wrote: Bob Dylan is poopy.That's why I made the first thread, this is a copycat thread -.-' >.< |
***Marial-B*** 31.05.2007 02:50 |
That's why I stopped and now I use dishwasher xD |
thomasquinn 32989 31.05.2007 12:45 |
<font color="magenta">Marial-B wrote: That's why I stopped and now I use dishwasher xDMy my. You DO have sins to do penance for, don't you? Oh wait, you do! That topic of yours! |
***Marial-B*** 31.05.2007 13:38 |
Well... there's some sort of democracy here |
thomasquinn 32989 01.06.2007 12:37 |
<font color="magenta">Marial-B wrote: Well... there's some sort of democracy hereAnd where would 'here' be? |
Raf 01.06.2007 15:30 |
<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: (...)but Dylan is an ace songwriter, a very good arranger (only Raf will deny this, but then again, he also thinks that The Edge is a good guitarist...)I never said he's some kind of guitar hero or anything. He's not very skilled, but he does his job. I believe he would be a terrible solo artist, but as a part of U2, he does his job, and he does it damn well. Bob Dylan, on the other hand, doesn't really do a good job with his own songs. I like his songs, I never said I hate his work. But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voices (well, they couldn't be really worse than the original voice anyway). So fuck off and stop misquoting me in every fucking post you write. |
~im a fool~ 01.06.2007 21:42 |
"i got the bob dylan blues and the bob dylan shoes and my clothes and my hairs in a mess. but to tell you i couldnt care less, cause im a poet, dont you know it? and the wind you can blow it, cause im mr. dylan the king and im free as a bird on the wing....!" |
thomasquinn 32989 03.06.2007 07:00 |
im a fool wrote: "i got the bob dylan blues and the bob dylan shoes and my clothes and my hairs in a mess. but to tell you i couldnt care less, cause im a poet, dont you know it? and the wind you can blow it, cause im mr. dylan the king and im free as a bird on the wing....!"Yes, you are indeed a fool. |
thomasquinn 32989 03.06.2007 07:08 |
<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:Misquoting? Well, first of all, I *didn't* quote you. Do you see quotation marks in my post? I did PARAPHRASE you, and quite correctly. You stated on several occasions, both on MSN and on this noticeboard that you though The Edge was a good guitarist, and that his solos are good.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: (...)but Dylan is an ace songwriter, a very good arranger (only Raf will deny this, but then again, he also thinks that The Edge is a good guitarist...)I never said he's some kind of guitar hero or anything. He's not very skilled, but he does his job. I believe he would be a terrible solo artist, but as a part of U2, he does his job, and he does it damn well. Bob Dylan, on the other hand, doesn't really do a good job with his own songs. I like his songs, I never said I hate his work. But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voices (well, they couldn't be really worse than the original voice anyway). So fuck off and stop misquoting me in every fucking post you write. But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voicesDid you know that when it comes to Bob Dylan-covers, most people tend to stick to HIS arrangements? Of course you didn't, because you are quite clueless, but still. Apart from a few exceptions (Guns 'n Roses, though they only changed KOHD marginally, really, and Bryan Ferry (and he DOES do a worse job vocally)) and on the rare occasion that a band covers a song Dylan performed solo (i.e. his work prior to 'going electric' in '65, which is covered rarely), the arrangements you hear are Dylan's. As for the vocals, I have never defended the position that Dylan is a great vocalist. He's not. But he's usually a DECENT vocalist (The Hurricane, The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll, When The Ship Comes In, etc.). In fact, it is excruciatingly difficult to sing the chorus of "Hattie Carroll" in key if you're not Dylan himself, to name but one example. |
***Marial-B*** 03.06.2007 07:31 |
<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote:Good one :P.<font color="magenta">Marial-B wrote: Well... there's some sort of democracy hereAnd where would 'here' be? In Canarias??? |
Raf 03.06.2007 10:42 |
<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote:About The Edge... Saying I think he's good and I like his solos doesn't mean I think he's a fucking guitar hero, it just means they sound good to me. Stop acting like you're even more stupid than you actually are.<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:Misquoting? Well, first of all, I *didn't* quote you. Do you see quotation marks in my post? I did PARAPHRASE you, and quite correctly. You stated on several occasions, both on MSN and on this noticeboard that you though The Edge was a good guitarist, and that his solos are good.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: (...)but Dylan is an ace songwriter, a very good arranger (only Raf will deny this, but then again, he also thinks that The Edge is a good guitarist...)I never said he's some kind of guitar hero or anything. He's not very skilled, but he does his job. I believe he would be a terrible solo artist, but as a part of U2, he does his job, and he does it damn well. Bob Dylan, on the other hand, doesn't really do a good job with his own songs. I like his songs, I never said I hate his work. But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voices (well, they couldn't be really worse than the original voice anyway). So fuck off and stop misquoting me in every fucking post you write.But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voicesDid you know that when it comes to Bob Dylan-covers, most people tend to stick to HIS arrangements? Of course you didn't, because you are quite clueless, but still. Apart from a few exceptions (Guns 'n Roses, though they only changed KOHD marginally, really, and Bryan Ferry (and he DOES do a worse job vocally)) and on the rare occasion that a band covers a song Dylan performed solo (i.e. his work prior to 'going electric' in '65, which is covered rarely), the arrangements you hear are Dylan's. As for the vocals, I have never defended the position that Dylan is a great vocalist. He's not. But he's usually a DECENT vocalist (The Hurricane, The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll, When The Ship Comes In, etc.). In fact, it is excruciatingly difficult to sing the chorus of "Hattie Carroll" in key if you're not Dylan himself, to name but one example. About Dylan's arrangements, how about Jimi's version of All Along The Watchtower? As far as I'm concerned, Dylan himself found Jimi's arrangement better and copied it on stage. |
thomasquinn 32989 03.06.2007 13:03 |
<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:And he accuses ME of being stupid? Wow. Raf, seriously. Listen to the two arrangements. Put them side-by-side. How different are they? Yes, indeed! Only marginally!<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote:About The Edge... Saying I think he's good and I like his solos doesn't mean I think he's a fucking guitar hero, it just means they sound good to me. Stop acting like you're even more stupid than you actually are. About Dylan's arrangements, how about Jimi's version of All Along The Watchtower? As far as I'm concerned, Dylan himself found Jimi's arrangement better and copied it on stage.<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:Misquoting? Well, first of all, I *didn't* quote you. Do you see quotation marks in my post? I did PARAPHRASE you, and quite correctly. You stated on several occasions, both on MSN and on this noticeboard that you though The Edge was a good guitarist, and that his solos are good.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: (...)but Dylan is an ace songwriter, a very good arranger (only Raf will deny this, but then again, he also thinks that The Edge is a good guitarist...)I never said he's some kind of guitar hero or anything. He's not very skilled, but he does his job. I believe he would be a terrible solo artist, but as a part of U2, he does his job, and he does it damn well. Bob Dylan, on the other hand, doesn't really do a good job with his own songs. I like his songs, I never said I hate his work. But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voices (well, they couldn't be really worse than the original voice anyway). So fuck off and stop misquoting me in every fucking post you write.But I tend to prefer cover versions both for the arrangement and for the better voicesDid you know that when it comes to Bob Dylan-covers, most people tend to stick to HIS arrangements? Of course you didn't, because you are quite clueless, but still. Apart from a few exceptions (Guns 'n Roses, though they only changed KOHD marginally, really, and Bryan Ferry (and he DOES do a worse job vocally)) and on the rare occasion that a band covers a song Dylan performed solo (i.e. his work prior to 'going electric' in '65, which is covered rarely), the arrangements you hear are Dylan's. As for the vocals, I have never defended the position that Dylan is a great vocalist. He's not. But he's usually a DECENT vocalist (The Hurricane, The Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll, When The Ship Comes In, etc.). In fact, it is excruciatingly difficult to sing the chorus of "Hattie Carroll" in key if you're not Dylan himself, to name but one example. |
Raf 03.06.2007 13:29 |
ThomasQueer... link ...talk to the hand. |
thomasquinn 32989 07.06.2007 05:54 |
When you have to resort to poor puns and sad clichés, it becomes painfully obvious that you are really just a sad little kid. |
The Fairy King 07.06.2007 06:03 |
You're becoming a cliché too Cas. Just ignore eachother please. -.-' |
Raf 07.06.2007 06:34 |
<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: When you have to resort to poor puns and sad clichés, it becomes painfully obvious that you are really just a sad little kid.You mentioning me in threads where I haven't even posted and didn't even have the intention to post is getting more cliché than newbies asking if Freddie was gay. Get a life and fucking forget I exist, you idiot. |
thomasquinn 32989 07.06.2007 10:02 |
<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:You seem to forget the part about 'relevance'. It was RELEVANT mentioning you, because you are the only person stupid enough to defend the position I used to illustrate my point.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: When you have to resort to poor puns and sad clichés, it becomes painfully obvious that you are really just a sad little kid.You mentioning me in threads where I haven't even posted and didn't even have the intention to post is getting more cliché than newbies asking if Freddie was gay. Get a life and fucking forget I exist, you idiot.See, that's where you make a critical mistake: you don't exist. You just believe you do. Think about it. |
Rick 07.06.2007 11:17 |
<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote:Thinking and non-existence don't match.<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:You seem to forget the part about 'relevance'. It was RELEVANT mentioning you, because you are the only person stupid enough to defend the position I used to illustrate my point.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: When you have to resort to poor puns and sad clichés, it becomes painfully obvious that you are really just a sad little kid.You mentioning me in threads where I haven't even posted and didn't even have the intention to post is getting more cliché than newbies asking if Freddie was gay.Get a life and fucking forget I exist, you idiot.See, that's where you make a critical mistake: you don't exist. You just believe you do. Think about it. |
thomasquinn 32989 07.06.2007 14:39 |
<font color=blue>Rick wrote:Not necessarily. You think, don't you? But you cannot prove to me, or to yourself, that you are NOT a delusion of your own mind.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote:Thinking and non-existence don't match.<font color="lime">Raf840 wrote:You seem to forget the part about 'relevance'. It was RELEVANT mentioning you, because you are the only person stupid enough to defend the position I used to illustrate my point.<b><font color = "crimson"> ThomasQuinn wrote: When you have to resort to poor puns and sad clichés, it becomes painfully obvious that you are really just a sad little kid.You mentioning me in threads where I haven't even posted and didn't even have the intention to post is getting more cliché than newbies asking if Freddie was gay.Get a life and fucking forget I exist, you idiot.See, that's where you make a critical mistake: you don't exist. You just believe you do. Think about it. Welcome to 20th century philosophy, we've been there, we've done that, and we still haven't found any answer (or question) to help us forward. |